I have the Superchips, Maganflow & the GM CAI on my Yukon and I have no regrets. All of the mods were spaced out, so I was able to test and evaluate each one seperately. The Superchips was first, I run it on the 91 octane setting and it by far was the best "bang for the buck". I recently had to return the vehicle to stock because of some dealer work and could really tell the difference in power! After having it, I HATED driving it stock especially on the freeway. After installing the Superchips I also saw an increase of .9 mpg. Then I added the Magnaflow exhaust and saw an increase of .5 mpg and couldn't really tell a difference in power. Pretty sure I could have gotten better, but I find myself stepping on it more just to hear the exhaust note. Then I added the GM CAI and I actually saw a decrease of .4 mpg and no noticeable increase in power. I wanted to stick with an oil-less filter and there weren't a whole lot of options. The GM is a nice unit, but maybe a little over priced. IMO the Superchips had the most noticeable increase in power/performance. If I had to do it over and only get 2 of the 3, it would definitely be the chip then the exhaust.
All mpg calculations were done over atleast 2500 miles and only about 5% highway driving.